The Daughter He Had Met Once
On 9 December 1992 a man of 46 asked a Seattle judge to release him on bail before prison. Most of it was ordinary. One paragraph was not. He wanted the weeks before lockup with “his 70-year-old mother, who is in extremely poor health,” and with “Bill’s two daughters, Carey, 18, and India, 1 1/2.”
Then the sentence that stops me. “Because of his incarceration in Germany, Bill has only seen his daughter India once in his life.”
Eighteen months old, and one visit. The child was India Riven Oxenberg, born 7 June 1991. Twenty five years later he surfaced again, at 71, calling her an angel and asking her to leave a group in Albany, New York.
A Birth Year Built Out of Three Numbers
No birthday, not one I can find. Three ages survive, and they agree: 46 in December 1992, 47 in July 1993, 71 in October 2017. Late 1945 to mid 1946, then.
A man with no known arrival and, stranger, no known exit. No death notice fits him. The name belongs to other men: a patent lawyer, a film editor, an optometrist, a legal analyst called Bill Sheaffer who died in 2026. None of them is the defendant in the marijuana case.
Two Men With the Same Three Names
Two lives, one string of names.
| The defendant | The Army officer | |
|---|---|---|
| Born | about 1946, place unknown | 8 April 1921, Greensburg, Pennsylvania |
| Died | no death found | 13 December 1972, age 51 |
| Buried | unknown | Gettysburg National Cemetery, 26 December 1972, Section 6 |
| Service | none known | Major, Adjutant General’s Corps, U.S. Army Reserve, active 26 February 1942 to 28 November 1945 |
The officer cannot be India’s father. He died nearly nineteen years before she was born.
He may be her grandfather. A family tree in wide circulation makes the Major the smuggler’s father: parents Adam Benjamin Charles Shaffer and Clara Mae Weitz, wife Jeanne M. Kesner, daughter of James Eliphaz Kesner and Agnes Gleeson. Christopher’s full name in April 1992 was Christopher Kesner Shaffer, and Kesner is the grandmother’s maiden name. Greensburg also sits in the Pittsburgh country the brothers came from.
None of that is a court finding. Nobody has put Jr. or II after his name in public, and a family name may have drifted onto the wrong generation. I hold the question open.
Eight Counts in Los Angeles
In September 1981 a grand jury in Los Angeles charged William Weitz Shaffer and three others with four narcotics counts and four tax counts, over a conspiracy from February 1975 to April 1977 to import and distribute cocaine. The government leaned on Robert Durand, an unindicted co-conspirator who described smuggling trips and enormous profits. On 7 May 1982 a jury convicted him on all eight counts.
Then it came apart. About two years later he moved for a new trial, arguing the government had hidden how valuable Durand was: a paid informant in a separate heroin operation in 1980 and 1981, the money he was given and spent, the assets he built, the civil tax case never brought. On 14 February 1985 the trial judge ordered a new trial. On 5 May 1986 the Ninth Circuit agreed.
What happened at a retrial, if there was one, I cannot tell you.
Sixty Five Tons and Three Different Fortunes
1986 and 1987. About 65 tons of marijuana grown in Thailand, moved by ship to rendezvous points off the West Coast, then onto fishing trawlers. One 23 ton load came ashore at Anacortes, Washington, and went by truck to a ranch near Bakersfield, California. Twenty three tons in 1986, forty two in 1987.
| Figure | What it actually describes |
|---|---|
| about $300 million | what the DEA said 65 tons was worth |
| $60 million | what prosecutors said those two years generated, laundered in Europe |
| more than $50 million | what authorities called the brothers’ take |
| about $3 million | forfeiture promised in the December 1992 plea |
| $1,025,000 | the check handed over in court in July 1993 |
Those are not the same kind of number. A street value is not a profit.
The money ran through Terry Fields, a Santa Monica lawyer who allegedly bought the First World Bank in the Cayman Islands, set up three dummy corporations with Swiss accounts for Shaffer, and used them partly to pay Vietnamese officials for access to Ho Chi Minh Harbor. Fields was never indicted. He gave up a Malibu beach property to avoid prosecution.
Thirteen and a Half Years
He was hunted for two years. Arrested in Germany in January 1992, he spent nine months in custody there, then was extradited to Seattle that September. In December he pleaded guilty to a 1987 importation count and agreed to plead to a California drug count and a Seattle money laundering charge. The deal called for 10 to 15 years, about $3 million in forfeiture, a full accounting of his assets, and one further condition: his brother had to surrender.
He asked to be freed until sentencing to see his family. Eight relatives and friends put up a proposed $2 million bond. Whether the judge allowed it is unclear.
On 9 July 1993 Judge John Coughenour sentenced him to 13 1/2 years and five years of supervised release. Christopher, younger by about three years, got 12 years and five. Three others drew four to seven years.
| Defendant | Prison | Supervised release | Forfeiture |
|---|---|---|---|
| William Weitz Shaffer | 13 1/2 years | 5 years | share of $1,025,000 |
| Christopher Shaffer | 12 years | 5 years | share of $1,025,000 |
| Dennis Specht | 7 years | not given | $200,000 |
| Kenneth Tarlow | 6 years | not given | $250,000 |
Forty seven people were convicted across a five year investigation. And someone carried a cashier’s check for $1,025,000 into the courtroom. Someone had to sign it.
India and the Thing Nobody Signed
The claim sat in that December 1992 request, twenty five years before anyone outside the courtroom noticed. What 2017 added was his own voice. At 71 he said: “I’ve had a close and personal relationship with my daughter India her entire life. I know in my heart she will do the right thing. She’s an angel.”
He met Catherine Oxenberg in Germany while he was a fugitive. She is the daughter of Princess Elizabeth of Yugoslavia and Howard Oxenberg. They did not marry. Her marriages were Robert Evans in 1998, annulled; Casper Van Dien in 1999, ended in divorce in 2015; and Ellis Jones in 2023.
What does not exist matters as much. No birth certificate naming him. No paternity judgment. No DNA test. No statement from Catherine naming him as the father, and none from India, not even in the years when she spoke at length about her mother. Christina Oxenberg, Catherine’s sister, once said India had been raised “forbidden to disclose the identity of her father.” The same telling concedes that nobody has said who imposed the ban. A ban is not a confirmation. It is not a denial either.
The Birthday That Does Not Fit
One thread will not pull straight. India’s first birthday was 7 June 1992, and in June 1992 he was in German custody, nine months of it, ending with extradition in September. Yet one unnamed recollection from 2017 placed him at a birthday party in Los Angeles, and added that Catherine brought India to the prison to visit.
The 1992 request came first and says he had seen her once. The prison visits after July 1993 are a separate claim, and undated. I do not know which memory is right. I know which was written down first.
Carey and the Long Silence After Her Name
Carey was 18 in December 1992, so born around 1974. That is nearly all of it. Her surname is not given. Her mother’s name has never been made public. One widely copied family sketch names a mother called Bobbie and a husband called Paul, and I will not repeat it as settled, because nothing else supports it.
Then she vanishes. India becomes the daughter everybody asks about. Two girls in the same line of type, and only one got a public life.
What Was Never Made Public
No profession. No employer. No degree. No legitimate business. No citizenship paper. No confirmed account. After prison, quietly, in Santa Monica, California.
The invented version is worth naming. In it he was born in 1943, has a stated height, a Christian affiliation, a marriage to Catherine Oxenberg, and a net worth of about $5 million in 2023. None of it holds. The $5 million borrows the smuggling figures and dresses them up as a bank balance.
FAQ
Was William Weitz Shaffer ever legally established as India Oxenberg’s father?
No. There is no paternity judgment, no birth certificate naming him, no DNA test. Only his own claim, made in December 1992 and repeated in October 2017.
Is he the William Weitz Shaffer buried at Gettysburg National Cemetery?
No. That man was a Major in the U.S. Army Reserve, born 8 April 1921 in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, and dead on 13 December 1972 at 51. He was buried on 26 December 1972, nearly nineteen years before she was born.
How much money did the smuggling operation actually make?
Nobody put a clean answer on the table. The 1986 and 1987 loads were described as generating $60 million, or as yielding the brothers more than $50 million, while the marijuana was valued at about $300 million. The plea promised about $3 million, and a check for $1,025,000 changed hands at sentencing.
What happened after the ruling that overturned the cocaine conviction?
Unknown. The new trial was ordered on 14 February 1985 and affirmed on 5 May 1986, and no outcome of any retrial has been made public.
Did he and Catherine Oxenberg ever marry?
There is no evidence of it. Her marriages were to Robert Evans in 1998, annulled; to Casper Van Dien in 1999, divorced in 2015; and to Ellis Jones in 2023.
Is he still alive?
I cannot say. No death notice matching him has turned up, and no public appearance after October 2017 has been confirmed. Absence of a death notice is not proof of life.